7 Master-Planned Communities Families Are Moving to in St. Johns County, FL
Lorilei Dennis May 9, 2026
Lorilei Dennis May 9, 2026
If you've been researching a move to Northeast Florida, you've probably already heard the name St. Johns County come up — and for good reason. This area has become one of the most sought-after destinations in the entire Southeast, offering a combination of top-rated public schools, beautiful natural surroundings, proximity to the beach and Jacksonville, and some of the most thoughtfully designed master-planned communities in the country.
What makes St. Johns County stand out isn't just one thing — it's everything working together. The lifestyle here is genuinely different from what most families experience elsewhere. Neighbors know each other. Kids play outside. There are trails to walk, events to attend, and a real sense of community that's increasingly hard to find.
If you're considering a relocation to this area and want to understand which communities might be the right fit for your lifestyle and your family's needs, this guide is for you. Here's an honest look at seven of the most popular master-planned communities in St. Johns County — what each one offers, what makes it distinctive, and what you should know before you visit.
1. Nocatee — Ponte Vedra Beach Area
Nocatee is consistently ranked among the top master-planned communities in the United States, and it's easy to see why. Located in Ponte Vedra in northern St. Johns County, Nocatee was built around the idea of a complete community — one where you can live, work, shop, and play without ever leaving the neighborhood.
The amenity package at Nocatee is genuinely impressive. Splash Water Park features Northeast Florida's tallest water slides, a lazy river, zip line, and multiple pools. The Greenway trail system winds through the community for biking, walking, and golf cart rides. The Town Center hosts a regular farmers market, dining, and retail. Community events are plentiful — from food truck nights to holiday celebrations that draw the whole neighborhood out.
Homes in Nocatee range from the mid-$500s to well over $1 million, with a wide variety of sub-neighborhoods, builders, and architectural styles. New construction is still available, though Nocatee is nearing build-out, making this a strong window to get in before inventory tightens further.
What to Know:
2. Shearwater — St. Augustine
Shearwater is one of the newer master-planned communities in St. Johns County, and it has quickly established itself as a favorite for those who want resort-style living with a more natural, laid-back feel. Set among mature trees and natural Florida landscape, the community has a distinctly serene atmosphere that sets it apart from some of the larger, more densely developed options in the area.
The centerpiece amenity is The Kayak Club — a stunning lakeside amenity center that includes a fitness lodge, gathering spaces, tennis courts, and a pool with a lazy river. Outdoor enthusiasts will love the miles of walking and biking trails that weave throughout the community's preserved greenery.
Shearwater is located in northern St. Johns County near the CR 210 corridor, which gives residents easy access to I-95 — making commutes to Jacksonville, Ponte Vedra, and downtown St. Augustine manageable. Homes range primarily from the mid-$400s to $700s, with a mix of new construction and resale available.
What to Know:
3. SilverLeaf — St. Augustine
SilverLeaf is one of the larger master-planned developments taking shape in St. Johns County, situated in the rapidly growing corridor along the St. Augustine side of I-95. It's a community that's still actively building, which means buyers today have excellent opportunities to customize new construction and get into an area that's still appreciating.
The community is designed around an active outdoor lifestyle, with trails, parks, and open space woven throughout. Amenities include clubhouse facilities, community pools, sports courts, and green spaces for recreation. The nearby Durbin Park Retail Center and other commercial development along this corridor have made SilverLeaf increasingly convenient for everyday needs.
SilverLeaf's price points are competitive for the area, making it one of the more accessible options for buyers looking to get into St. Johns County with new construction. The community sits within the top-rated St. Johns County school district.
What to Know:
4. Beachwalk — St. Johns County (Northern)
Beachwalk is unlike anything else in St. Johns County — and that's not marketing language, it's simply true. The community's crown jewel is a 14-acre Crystal Lagoon, a man-made body of water with Caribbean-blue clarity that residents can swim, paddleboard, and kayak in year-round. It's a genuinely one-of-a-kind amenity in this part of Florida.
Beyond the lagoon, Beachwalk features a clubhouse, fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts, and a lifestyle programming calendar that keeps residents connected. The community is located in northern St. Johns County near the intersection of I-95 and CR 9B, offering excellent highway access and proximity to both Jacksonville and the Ponte Vedra area.
Homes in Beachwalk range from townhomes to single-family homes, with prices generally starting in the $400s and going up from there depending on size and finishes. The community appeals strongly to those who prioritize a resort-inspired lifestyle and an amenity that genuinely can't be replicated.
What to Know:
5. RiverTown — St. Johns County
RiverTown is a master-planned community positioned along the scenic St. Johns River, offering something rare in Northeast Florida: genuine waterfront character built into the fabric of the neighborhood. Trails, overlooks, and community spaces are designed to take advantage of the river setting, giving RiverTown a distinctly natural, peaceful feel.
The amenity package centers around The Riverhouse and The RiverClub — a clubhouse complex that includes resort-style pools, a fitness center, event lawn, fishing pier, hiking and biking trails, and pickleball and bocce courts. The community hosts regular resident events throughout the year that contribute to a strong neighborhood culture.
RiverTown is located off CR 210 in southern St. Johns County, with easy access to I-95 and approximately 25 minutes from downtown St. Augustine. Home prices range from the mid-$500s into the $1 millions and above, with multiple neighborhoods and builders within the larger community.
What to Know:
6. TrailMark — St. Augustine
TrailMark is a community that earns its name. Positioned in northern St. Johns County with direct access to Six Mile Creek, TrailMark residents enjoy access to some of the most beautiful natural trails in the region right outside their doors. If outdoor living and connection to Florida's natural landscape is a priority, TrailMark is worth a serious look.
The community amenities include a clubhouse, resort-style pool, fitness center, sports courts, and extensive trail connectivity throughout. The atmosphere here tends to feel a bit more tucked away and nature-forward compared to some of the larger amenity-driven communities, which many residents find genuinely appealing.
TrailMark sits along US-1 in northern St. Johns County, placing it close to historic St. Augustine while also offering reasonable access north toward Ponte Vedra and Jacksonville. Home prices generally range from the mid-$400s to $700s, with active new construction available.
What to Know:
7. Beacon Lake — St. Augustine
Beacon Lake is one of the smaller communities in the St. Johns County master-planned community landscape, and it's been turning heads since it opened. The community is centered around a 43-acre lake.
Beacon Lake offers a well-appointed amenity center with a resort-style pool, fitness facilities, parks, and trails. The community has a modern, design-forward aesthetic, and the homes reflect that with contemporary floor plans and finishes from its builder lineup.
Located in St. Augustine along the CR 210 corridor, Beacon Lake offers solid connectivity to I-95 and is within the St. Johns County school district. Home prices start in the mid-$400s and move up depending on the collection and homesite.
What to Know:
So Which Community Is Right for You?
That's exactly the right question — and the honest answer is that it depends entirely on your lifestyle, your daily priorities, and what you want your mornings and weekends to look like.
Some families want the resort-style energy of Nocatee or Beachwalk. Others want the natural beauty and quiet of TrailMark or RiverTown. Some are drawn to the lakefront adventure of Beacon Lake. Others prioritize access to I-95 for an easy commute, or want to be just minutes from historic St. Augustine.
There's no universally right answer — but there is a right answer for you. What I do with every relocation client is take the time to understand how your family actually lives before we ever look at a single floor plan. Because finding a home isn't just about square footage and finishes. It's about how your daily life feels when you're in it.
I'd love to help you explore these communities — virtually or in person — and find the one that genuinely fits.
Ready to Start Your St. Johns County Search?
Whether you're relocating from out of state, making a move within Florida, or just beginning to research your options, I'm here to help you navigate this in a way that feels steady and informed — never overwhelming.
Reach out anytime. I'd love to talk through where you are in the process and answer your questions about any of these communities.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Whether you're buying your first home, upgrading, or investing, Lorilei ensures you get the best options and the right deal. With a personalized approach, you’re guided every step of the way—from property search to closing—making the entire process smooth and stress-free.